Monday, April 19, 2010

Competition Result: competition number 2.

And so, Kirk has done it again! Within a few minutes of the second competition being posted to this blog, earlier this afternoon, our last winner, Countdown champion Kirk Bevins, 23 year old maths teacher from York, immediately and correctly spotted the ten anagrams and emailed me the answers, which are as follows:

  1. TRANSLATE
  2. RENDERING
  3. EMBELLISH
  4. EXPLICATE
  5. NORMATIVE
  6. CAUSATION
  7. CAUSALITY
  8. INTERPRET
  9. MODIFYING
  10. REDUCTION (but, as Kirk pointed out, an alternative answer would be INTRODUCTION, but he opted for REDUCTION given that I was looking for a Translation Theory term, and he got it right, though I would have accepted INTRODUCTION also). But how might I propose a link between 'introduction' and Translation?

Congratulations, Kirk. Can he make it a hat trick when I post the next anagram competition in a few week's time? Another copy of Around the World in Eighty Days shall be winging its way to York this week, except this time - gasp - it's a translation by Jacqueline Rogers. I'm sure Kirk can't wait. Tell you what - next time I shall try to vary the competition format, as i've previously promised on this blog, i.e. I will include literary quiz questions and numbers games.

Competition number 2!

Today's posting deals with the second of my anagram competitions for readers of this blog. The last competition dealt with words connected to the writings of Jules Verne, and you may remember that the winner was Mr Kirk Bevins of York, U.K. This new competition is open to anybody to enter, but it may be of particular interest to fellow Translation Studies scholars, as you shall see...

Please unscramble the following jumbled words, to come up with ten words which are all terms in Translation Studies. No clues are provided this time round, as i'm deliberately seeking to up the ante. The prize for the first set of completely correct answers e-mailed to me at the address in the next paragraph, will be the 1994 revised translation of Around the World in Eighty Days by Jacqueline Rogers.

Solutions, with your name and postal address, should be e-mailed to me at kieran.odriscoll3@mail.dcu.ie before the closing date of 12 noon on Monday, 3rd May, 2010.

  1. A R T E S A T L N
  2. E N I E R N D R G
  3. H E M I E L B S L
  4. L A X E E C I P T
  5. V A N I R E T O M
  6. T A U S A C N O I
  7. C I S A U T L A Y
  8. P E N T I E R R T
  9. G O Y M I D F I N
  10. D U R E C T I O N

I look forward to receiving the entries and to announcing the winner in a couple of weeks time. So come on, Translation scholars: can you get there before Kirk Bevins?!!

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Book Review - French folk tales - Henri Pourrat


Because part of the mission of this blog is to speak about literature in other languages, which has been translated and/or is often itself a translation from another language and/or medium, I want to use this posting to talk about a French writer who has very recently been making an impact on me. You know how much I love children's literature, especially in French. SO here's an article I've put together about a writer called Henri Pourrat who has collected many regional, traditional tales throughout France, and published them over many years during the twentieth- century. I'm not yet sure if Pourrat's tales have been translated into English, but I think it would be a welcome initiative.


Les fous et les sages (Le Tresor des contes) (French Edition)
A collection of folk tales with a difference!


I still have many more of the wonderful collected folk-tales of the French writer Henri Pourrat to enjoy over the coming months and years, and this prospect is, of course, for me, an enormous treat, given that I have always really enjoyed reading all sorts of tales (’contes’) in both English and, especially, French, over many years but especially nowadays since I began studying and researching French literature and reading translated and adapted literature in earnest over the last twelve years.

Thus have I greatly enjoyed, in both English (translation) and in French, the classic, often adapted and varied in numerous versions, stories of Hans Christian Andersen (translated from Danish, which I don’t unfortunately read, into French and English etc), the Grimm Brothers, Wilhelm and Jacob, (in French and English renderings), the ’Contes du chat perché’ (Contes rouges, bleus, etc.) by Marcel Aymé, and collections of ’contes’ from Greek and Roman mythology in French, together with anthologies of such stories from many other traditions. These include the collected traditional, regional folklore tales of such French regions as the Languedoc, Picardie, Auvergne, Paris and of the Middle Ages in France. I can recommend the Dublin-based médiathèque of the Alliance Français, at 1, Kildare Street, Dublin 2, for access to a veritable cavern of such treasures of children’s and popular, traditional French and Francophone literature which, of course, appeals to all age groups. The wonderful tropes and images to be found in the works of contemporary fantasy writers such as J.K. Rowling, are echoed, back into the mists of time, by the witches, wizards and mythical creatures of the most traditional, simplest tales. An ideal way to relax at night is to dip into one or several of these delightful contes and to literally be transported from your armchair to an escape to a parallel world intertwined with our own.

But to talk specifically about Pourrat; this writer undertook a project in the twentieth century which is reminiscent of that of Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm in the Germany of a century earlier. Pourrat collected French regional tales from the countryside, villages, forests and high mountains of many French rural communities, listening to the born storytellers who, perhaps like Ireland’s Kitty the Hare, had a special gift for telling a story to a group of enthralled listeners, using special local, intimate, colloquial language and traditional oral storytelling narrative techniques to capture and retain the rapt attention of her (not exclusively young, by any means) listeners. When reading Pourrat, one is constantly aware of the colloquial, oral, aural language experience and of the immediacy of the intimate storytelling moment.

Pourrat published his Treasury of Tales between 1948 and 1962, and the tales have often, as in the book being reviewed here, been selected according to different themes by other anthologists and published as shorter thematic collections. For instance, Pourrat’s collection of Christmas-related tales describes the magical adventures of country people, farmers, tailors, shopkeepers, princesses, fairy godmothers, local curés etc., on Christmas Eve. The tales all seem strongly anchored, then, in specific rural locales in deepest ’provinces’ all over France. Yet they often combine their local flavour and local, idiosyncratic, often archaic rural dialect and lexis with clear influences of universal themes equally present in Grimm, Perrault and also in world myths.

Local characters thus, in Pourrat’s world, have their kind deeds rewarded at Christmas through unexpected meetings with Joseph, Mary and the Infant Jesus, and with the Angels who heralded his birth, and with the shepherds and indeed the farmyard animals present in the stable to breathe on the newborn Christ to keep him warm. (Remember, on Christmas Eve, all animals can use human speech to communicate in memory of those Nativity animals and can thus help humans).

An example of Pourrat’s informants making universal tales specific to their own lived, local experience, is the tale of a childless couple of bakers who have their wish for a son or daughter finally granted through the sudden appearance of a sort of little ’bonhomme’ who forms himself from the scrappings of ingredients of his parents’ baking recipes. Tom Thumb, Thumbelina and the Little Gingerbread Man, of course, instantly come to mind. And just like those other miniscule creatures, Pourrat’s discovered infinitesimally small child becomes a great source of fun and adventure, helping his parents achieve wealth and happiness, and surviving a series of dangerous adventures, in which he variously finds himself swallowed several times by the same wolf, by a cow, a fox, and so on.

A couple who long to be wealthy are offered three wishes by a fairy godmother, but their hapless wishes bring nothing more than a long string of pudding which then attaches itself to the wife’s nose. In the end, they realise that fun and happiness arre more desirable in life than material wealth. The ’moralité’ of the worldwide ’conte’ is, therefore, often a feature of Pourrat’s collected tales. These specific examples are from a collection of Pourrat’s ’Christmas’-themed tales. However, the overall themes of the intensely local, and uses of local, intimate language, apply to all of Pourrat’s contes.

What I most love about Pourrat’s short stories are the very qualities he states that he has sought to infuse them with. These qualities include the following. The language use is non-standard and oral, so that the reader can truly ’hear’ the fireside storyteller engage her listeners; the vocabulary is often little-known as it refers to very specific local plants, flowers, creatures, foods, giving us the authentic ’terroir’ in which the tale unfolds. The oral storyteller is transferred to the page by Pourrat, yes; but the raconteurs whose tales are documented so lovingly and painstakingly by Pourrat do not lose their authentic ’voices’ in the (inter-semiotic, intra-lingual) ’translation’ from an oral to a written medium. Rather, Pourrat’s writerly mission - superbly accomplished - has been to bring local speech and characters alive, and to convey and preserve the local dialects of the regions and the idiolects of the individual speakers.
If, for example, you as an Irish reader enjoyed the tales of Kitty the Hare or Sile de Valera, among many others, and if you read French, I urge to you to try out Pourrat’s stories. Where Grimm and Perrault versions are often presented to us in a standardized form of language, Pourrat’s tales are steeped in place and people, making the local community universal, in much the same way that the contemporary Carrick-on-Suir poet Michael Coady brings his (and my) small provincial native town to life, making our particular place universal. Pourrat and Coady celebrate the wonderful local characters, local tales and perhaps urban myths, local traditions, local events and things and most of all, local dialect and idiolects. This is the people’s spontaneously produced oral poetry, as Coady has noted of some of his work (e.g. in which he sees colourful, traditional local nicknames as passed down from father to son, mother to daughter, uncle to nephew, etc. as an example of such poetry and local character and humour).
For Coady, and Pourrat, the magic is not merely in the events recounted, but also in the homeliness and tradition of small places, the village, the small town, its nearby rivers and mountains which regulate daily life over centuries, the forest and the countryside and their local legends, those unique small communities which are the ’universe’ of their small and closely-bound groups of citizens.

Post-Scriptum:

One fact I omitted to mention in my previous posting: Kirk Bevins, our first competition winner, spotted all five anagrams correctly in a fraction of a second without needing the clues I provided! This is the type of feat regularly accomplised by him at the end of many Countdown episodes, in which the players are shown a nine-letter scrambled word and have to buzz in with the correct answer before their opponent spots it, so both are given a maximum of thirty seconds to unravel the conundrum.

Most of the top players like Kirk usually spot the conundrum almost immediately (and there are no clues to help them). Sometimes they buzz in with the answer before the thirty-second clock has even been started! Kirk is, of course, one of those contestants who could spot such conundrums within micro-seconds, as he did with this blog's competition.


The advantage for other entrants to this blog's tests is that you don't have such a rigorous time limit. So you will have plenty of time, if you don't see a word immediately, to play around with the letters. So it's not a question of speed in this blog's case, whereas speed is part of the thrill of playing and watching Countdown.

On the other hand, even this blog requires entrants to get their answers in by e-mail before anybody else, so do work quickly enough!

And my first winner is ...

Following the very first Verne-related and Countdown/Scrabble-related competition which I placed on this blog on the 26th February 2010, i'm delighted to announce that this blog now has its very first competition winner!

The five conundrums answers were, of course:

  1. ADVENTURE
  2. EXPLORING
  3. DISCOVERY
  4. SUBMARINE
  5. LONGITUDE.

And the winner is a rather special entrant: it's young Countdown wunderkind Kirk Bevins, maths teacher who was the first Countdown champion of 2009's six-month series with a total record score which broke the existing very high record, held by Julian Fell since 2001, for the highest total number of points every won in the 27-year history of this iconic Channel 4 afternoon programme which specializes in testing contestants in solving anagrams and very tough sums in thirty seconds or less. You may remember it was hosted for many years by maths genius Carol Vorderman and the late, great Richard Whiteley, who sadly passed away in 2005 and is still much-missed by his legions of devoted Countdown fans, as is Carol since she left the show after years of distinguished service.

But the show continues to maintain its high popularity, in the capable hands of presenter Jeff Stelling of Sky Sports fame, and of Oxford Maths genius Rachel Riley, who has stepped most ably into the (very hard to fill) shoes of numbers genius Carol, who is now involved in many other projects.

And the anagrammatic and arithmetical prodigies continue to enter the show in hordes and, like our blog winner Kirk, continue to show that astounding records are always there to be broken.

Kirk is due to make a welcome reappearance to our screens on the 15th March, 2010, for a one-off very special game in which he will pit his wits against those of current record-holder Chris Davies, the most recent series champion, and as only a miniscule number of points already separate these two Achilles of Anagrammia, the outcome of such a Clash of the Titans is simply anyone's guess. Worth betting some money on, I would think. But even if you don't usually watch Countdown, this will be a historic, classic duel not to be missed. So set those video-recorders if you're not at home that afternoon...

It's a kudo for this blog to have its first competition won by a world-class professional anagrammer. So this is the standard you will be up against, folks; so all you Translation Theorists out there, I challenge you to take on the might of the Kirkulator Bevins in future competitions for anagrams. The next anagrams will all, as i've said in a previous posting, be words which are Translation Theory concepts, so will that give you Translation people any advantage over a Countdown champion? Watch this space and find out, competition due to appear shortly. Plus some numbers games, Countdown style, using numbers with Vernian connections but still using the range of numbers and numerical targets acceptable under Countdown rules.

A copy of the 2009 edition of Verne's The Tour of the World in Eighty Days (1873), first translated by the Philadelphia-based translator Stephen W. White in 1874, and containing beautiful original illustrations and new critical material, including two essays i've written for it, one co-authored with Verne savant Norman Wolcott, is winging its way to York as we speak, to add to Kirk's existing book collection, viz. the entire leather-bound set of the complete Oxford English Dictionary which he won on Countdown.

Well done, Kirk!

Friday, February 26, 2010

Competition Time!

I now intend to introduce a new regular feature to this blog, viz., a series of competitions related to Verne Studies, literature generally, and Translation Studies.

The first competition, set out hereunder, is what I call the Verne Conundrum Competition. If you are a fan of the board game Scrabble, or of such television programmes as Channel 4's long-running words (anagrams) and numbers puzzle show Countdown, or of the French afternoon quiz Des Chiffres et des Lettres, you may particularly enjoy the type of puzzles I am giving here. You will probably also enjoy unscrambling these particular anagrams if you are a fan of the works of Jules Verne.

If you are interested in entering this competition, please email your answers to me at kieran.odriscoll3@mail.dcu.ie including a postal address to which I can send you the prize, which is, for this first competition, a copy of the newly republished The Tour of the World in Eighty Days, by Jules Verne, translated by the Philadelphia-based translator Stephen W. White in 1874. This is a beautiful edition with all of the original illustrations and new critical material, and is published by the Choptank Press, USA. It is not available in bookshops, but only through http://www.lulu.com/ and will constitute a valuable addition and collector's item in the library of any Verne reader or book lover generally.

This book will be posted to the e-mailer of the first fully correct set of (5) answers to the five 'scrambled word' puzzles below..

So here's what you have to do: I set out hereunder five words which are all in some way connected to the themes of Jules Verne's Extraordinary Journeys to the known and unknown worlds (Voyages Extraordinaires dans les mondes connus et inconnus), his lifelong opus of approximately sixty novels and novellas on themes of exploration, geography and science, among other topics.

The letters of each word have been randomly scrambled, so you need to rearrange them and tell me what the five words are. This puzzle is based on the exact same principle as applies on each of the Countdown letter games and conundrums/teasers, all of which involve solving anagrams. It is similarly based on Scrabble principles.

To make this first competition relatively easy, and to encourage as many blog readers as possible to enter, and emerge from the cyber-woodwork, I have given a clue as to what each word might be. These clues are somewhat akin to the Teatime Teasers on Countdown, the difference being that the following clues are not funny or pun-based, rather, they are straight and po-faced. First, here are two examples:

NAOHRPORE. Clue: This was the profession of Ned Land in Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Seas. Answer: HARPOONER.

OSODCNEIL. Clue: This word describes what France did to certain African countries and features in such Verne works as Voyages d'Etudes. Answer: COLONISED.

So here are the five conundrums you need to solve in order to win the Verne book collector's item which is the prize for this first competition:

1. T E R V A E D U N
Clue: This word describes a primary theme of practically all of Jules Verne's fictional works.

2. O L I E G X R P N

Clue: This word also describes a theme of virtually all of Verne's works, and is to the forefront in such novels as 'Journey to the Centre of the Earth' and 'Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Seas'.

3. Y R O D I C E V S

Clue: This word again describes a theme of most of Verne's fiction.

4. R A S B U I E M N

Clue: This word is the name of the mode of nautical transport captained by Nemo in 'Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Seas' (a giveaway, this one!)

5. D E L O U T I N G

Clue: A geographical measurement concept which proves important in 'Around the World in Eighty Days'.

As I say, if you are interested in taking part, please send your five answers, together with a postal address, by e-mail to me at kieran.odriscoll3@mail.dcu.ie . The book will be immediately posted to the winner.

The second competition will be published on this blog in about a month's time. The theme of this second challenge will be to solve ten conundrums/anagrams all relating to concepts in Translation Theory. And this time, there won't be any clues, so I will be upping the ante! The prize will be another Verne-related book.

Future competitions will include varied themes such as short quizzes on Verne's life and works, and quizzes on other writers, which could include anybody from Philip Pullman to J.K. Rowling or Lemony Snicket, including questions on the French translations and translators of these popular authors. There will also be occasional competitions seeking a short essay on a set topic in Translation Studies and literary studies. The best essays will be published on this blog. Future prizes will also include - apart from books - copies of the Scrabble and Countdown board games.

So, I hope you will enjoy this, and future, competitions. And I look forward to receiving solutions in the coming days!

Bonne chance et bon courage!

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Publication news

It's been quite a while since I last posted an article to this blog. The last few months have been very busy but productive. Thus, in the intervening period since I last wrote a piece for St Jerome's Warblings, there have been a few positive developments on the academic front.

Firstly, I submitted the hard-bound copies of my PhD thesis - Around the World in Eighty Changes: a diachronic study of the multiple causality of six complete translations (1873-2004), from French to English, of Jules Verne's novel Le tour du monde en quatre-vingts jours (1873) - to the University (Dublin City University), and am due to graduate next month. So it's a great relief to have the PhD process finally completed, and to now be able to look forward to new challenges.

Secondly, i've published two articles on the 1874 translation of the above Verne novel, into English, by the Philadelphia-based translator, Stephen W. White. The articles appear in a 2009 republication by the Choptank Press, US, of White's very accurate, close rendering (which he has entitled The Tour of the World in Eighty Days) of Verne's celebrated novel. One of the articles is entitled Putting White to Rights: re-evaluating the Verne translations of Stephen W. White, and is mainly a descriptive-explanatory analysis of White's translation decisions, and of the various causal influences which together culminated in his producing this unusually (for a Victorian-era rendering of Verne into English) accurate, complete and imitative translation.

The second article in the foregoing republication is co-authored with the editor of this new edition, Dr Norman Wolcott of the US, a Verne savant, and is entitled 'Who was Stephen White?' This article gives a detailed biographical outline of White's professional activities as a jobbing translator of commerical, legal and literary texts, as a stenographer and phonographer, as an employee and later director of a Pennsylvania railroad company, in 1870s Philadelphia, and includes photos and copies of documents from the archives, e.g. a photo of White himself from a high-school almanach, copies of notices in his local newspaper advertising his services as a translator, and so on.

The editor of this publication, Norman Wolcott, continues to perform Trojan work in bringing the unjustly forgotten yet highly competent Victorian translators of Verne, out of the crypt of history and into a 21st century spotlight. Such translators include White himself, together with Frederick Amadeus Malleson, another 19th-century translator of such Verne novels as A Journey into the Interior of the Earth, a rendering first published in 1877.

Wolcott has also penned an Introduction to this republished White rendering. This beautiful edition also contains all of the original illustrations by Neuville and Bennett.

Regretfully, this book is thus far available only through online ordering, on www.lulu.com, but it deserves, I feel, a much wider distribution network, including a presence in bookstores. It deserves to do well for Wolcott.

I'm also currently in the process of translating some early novellas, and end-of-career novels, of Jules Verne, for the North American Jules Verne Society. The first text i've almost finished translating is entitled Jédédias Jamet, or the tale of an inheritance, three chapters written by Verne in his early twenties and subsequently abandoned by him, though it seems that he had intended to make this work into a full-length novel, for which he had composed an outline. The text is satirical, and rather bizarre in parts, and is peppered liberally with legal, mythological, historical and religious references. I have explained these references in footnotes, and intend to post an article in the near future, describing some of these references and discussing the manner in which the translatorial footnotes help to fulfill the so-called 'didactic function of translation' (Brownlie, 2003).

Other than that, i'm busily applying for whatever academic posts seem to be currently advertised, in the areas of Translation Studies and/or French and Spanish Studies. The hopeful, bright spot on the horizon for all of us newly-minted PhDs is that, in many areas such as Translation Studies and French, there seems to be quite a few academic posts out there, in such locations as the United Kingdom, the USA and even a recently-posted advertisement for a French lecturer or Assistant Lecturer in the University of the West Indies (UWI), Bridgetown, Barbados. Plus, a vacancy in Queen's University, Belfast, for a lecturer in Translation Studies with French and Spanish.

The foregoing vacancies can all be viewed on the website www.jobs.ac.uk.

I'm currently editing an article i've had accepted for the online US journal of Verne Studies, Verniana, dealing with abridged and adapted translations of Verne's 80 Days for younger readers, and that should appear in September, 2010; it currently requires to be drastically shortened (ironically, given that the subject matter of the article is the very process of shortening text). The number of examples I tend to give in articles generally, of actual translated stretches of text, is too voluminous. One thing i've learned through the thesis-writing and editing process, especially during the post-viva corrections, is that there is a better, clearer, more concise method of presenting the findings, in synthesized form, of Descriptive-Explanatory Translation Studies (DTS) research; namely, it is preferable to not cite all of the coupled pairs of source and target text segments you've analysed, even in an Appendix.

Instead, the researcher needs to identify, from his/her copious empirical micro-textual examples of shifts and their causes, the most salient recurring features of the shifts in question, and discuss these shift types, and their probable underlying causes, with one or two examples.

Thus, in an abridged version of 80 Days, the researcher might want to discuss salient features such as simplification of language, reduction and omission of complex characterization and of physical description of people and places, with a privileging of plot and action over psychological complexities of characterization, and so on. Giving too many examples in a report on DTS findings, is akin to not being able to see the wood for the trees.